Let us take the example shown above for fixed & profit sharing fee working. As per that,
| Net Returns (Pre-Tax) to the Investor = A-B |
= |
Rs 25.60 |
| Add back Management & Performance Fee expenses = Rs 25.60 + Rs 4.40 |
= |
Rs 30.00 |
Our experience shows that about 70% of the gains in our portfolio is of long-term nature and the rest arises from short-term gains. Assuming the continuity of this trend,
| Long-term gains |
= |
21 00 (70% of Rs 30.00) (taxed at 10% rate) |
| Short-term gains |
= |
9.00 (30% of Rs 30.00) ( taxed at 15% rate) |
| Tax incidence |
= |
3.45 |
| The net post tax returns (estimate) |
= |
Rs 25.60 minus 3.45 = Rs 22.15* |
This example shows that the tax incidence is likely to be very small relative to the expected annual returns.
Note: * For simplification, the above illustration doesn't include GST on fee expense.
* Also we have not facted fee expenses in the computation.